Which Wartortle do you have?

Same name, 227× the price: $0.99 to $225 raw. The difference is printed on the card — it is just not somewhere most people think to look.

Base Set 1st Edition · #42 A black 1st Edition stamp below the left of the illustration. These are also shadowless - the stamp is the thing to look for first. $94 4.7% gem Base Set Shadowless · #42 No stamp, and no drop shadow down the right edge of the illustration frame. The card looks flatter and slightly paler than the common printing. $16 12% gem Base Set Unlimited · #42 A drop shadow down the right edge of the illustration frame. This is the common printing - most Base Set cards people own are this one. $3.10 15% gem Base Set 2 · #63 A set symbol in the lower right of the illustration. The 1999 Base Set printings have no set symbol at all, so its presence settles it immediately. $2.85 17% gem T Promos · #012 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $225 60% gem Intro Pack (Squirtle) · #10 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $85 41% gem Intro Pack (Squirtle) · #3 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $75 40% gem WOTC Promo · #63 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $65 no PSA data Pokemon Card 151 · #171 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $63 25% gem Trading Card Game Classic Japanese Blastoise · #002 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $49 78% gem Southern Islands Japanese · #008 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $48 24% gem Southern Islands · #15 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $45 24% gem Black & White Promos · #166 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $26 30% gem Pokemon Card 151 Japanese · #171 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $21 70% gem Expedition · #92 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $16 22% gem Fire Red Leaf Green · #50 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $15 45% gem Battle Starter Deck (Blastoise) · #002 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $7.52 58% gem Expansion Pack · #008 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $5.83 27% gem Blastoise Kyurem-EX Combo Deck · #002 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $5.38 no PSA data Blastoise Starter Deck · #019 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $3.42 57% gem Crystal Guardians · #42 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.64 13% gem Full Metal Wall · #009 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.46 25% gem Platinum · #65 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.23 14% gem Secret Wonders · #75 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.22 5.6% gem Plasma Blast · #15 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.14 7.7% gem Crystal Guardians · #43 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $2.06 24% gem Unleashed · #42 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.96 10% gem Tag Bolt · #022 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.89 75% gem Pokemon Card 151 · #008 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.79 30% gem Unbroken Bonds · #34 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.72 10% gem Pokemon GO Japanese · #016 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.68 90% gem Pokemon GO · #016 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.67 18% gem Boundaries Crossed · #30 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.49 29% gem Team Up · #24 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.29 29% gem Pokemon Card 151 Japanese · #008 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $1.21 79% gem Tag Team GX All Stars · #030 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. $0.99 85% gem Shining Darkness · #028 Check the set symbol in the lower right of the illustration, and the copyright year along the bottom edge. Those two identify the print run on every card that has them. — no PSA data

Prices are raw market value. Click a printing for its full grading verdict — the gem rate, the fees and whether it beats selling raw.